top of page
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube

The risk of risk management: Why combinations of data sharing barriers are the biggest barrier for customs interoperability ... and how to avoid them.

Oct 28
3 min read

There is a fundamental tension between a very strong need for data sharing between customs organisations – with widespread support – and the barriers to doing so.

On the one hand, support for more data sharing has come from the World Customs Organisation, the Wise Persons Group report on the Reform of the EU Customs, the Financial Action Task Force set up by the G7 to fight money laundering, and many other significant bodies. Indeed, the success of the new EU Customs Authority at risk management will depend on it.


On the other hand, there are many individual types of data sharing barriers. Not only technical and legal barriers – including differing interpretations of laws – but barriers caused by differences and separations in organisational structures, purposes or mandates; cultural norms; the prioritisation of resources; capacity; operational secrecy; downstream workflows and consequences; even the choice of words used in the data request; and other drivers.

This is important because even though data sharing happens there could be so much more. Data sharing barriers significantly limit data sharing that would help risk management decisions and decisions about where best to use resources.


In our research we found that the problem with data sharing is that individual data sharing barriers combine in complex ways to make it very difficult to judge the risk of authorising a specific data share, especially for the first time. This is the perceived risk of the person who is asked to authorise. If they can’t judge the risk, then it’s too risky.


This has the largest effect on ad hoc analyses – non-standard, speculative or non-routine analyses – that potentially move individual investigations forward and that might also lead to larger scale methods.


The perceived complexity of the risks of data sharing and the potential consequences for anyone who authorises them are the real barriers to data sharing.

The mix of data sharing barriers and risks are different for every bilateral sharing relationship – and even in each sharing direction. But they are drawn from a single set of risks and barriers, and they are not interdependent. Which means they are merely complicated not complex.

So, it is possible to understand the risks of each potential data share to the sharing organisation, as well as to the authoriser.


Using this insight, we have developed a simple method of assessing the risks of data sharing based on two new models, a Data Trail Model (DTM) and a Bilateral Asymmetric Data Sharing Model (BADS). This method is described in our Policy paper and it can also help to assess which data sources to approach for which data and what the benefits are of doing so. This is important because a common barrier is not knowing what data is out there, who to source it from, or why it is worth sourcing.


The DTM model helps with visualising what new data and data sources might be available. It connects direct and indirect data sources; the journey stages and super stages of travelling entities, like people, vehicles and cargoes; past actual data records and future potential records; organisational information perspectives; organisation data sources; levels of analysis in supply chains; and the data trails that are produced by entities’ behaviours as they travel.

This enables customs analysts to choose abstract and low risk data which still helps an investigation to progress, but which is easier to request from sources to initiate new data sharing relationships.


The BADS model helps potential data source organisations to assess the risks of sharing different data with different requestors. It breaks down data sharing barriers into simpler barrier combinations that only apply to specific bilateral shares in a single direction. Simplifying the mixes of barriers in this way makes it easier to persuade the authoriser because they can more easily assess the risk to their organisation, themselves, and their careers.


Together the two models support increased data sharing by reducing the perceived and actual risk of sharing and by increasing the number of options for which data to use and which sources to get it from, so it also improves data analysis strategies.


If you are interested in learning more about these data sharing methods, please contact us here.




 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page